Bởi Toby Fox tobyfox Bandcamp tobyfox Twitter toby.fangamer.com Khác fwugradiation Tumblr ← Nautical Climb Bài hát trước đó bởi tác giả này → Plasmatic Blaquaciousness Bài hát tiếp theo bởi tác giả này.

Nghe tại YouTube hoặc YouTube.

Đọc tại nguồn liên hệ.

Bài hát mà Penumbra Phantasm có liên hệ đến:

• Doctor bởi Buzinkai và Clark Powell

Bài hát có liên hệ đến Penumbra Phantasm:

trong Official Discography:

• Savior of the Waking World bởi Toby Fox
• Octoroon Rangoon bởi Toby Fox
• Planet Healer bởi Seth Peelle
• Get Up bởi Toby Fox
• Descend bởi Toby Fox
• Umbral Ultimatum bởi Toby Fox
• Heir Conditioning bởi Tensei
• Savior of the Dreaming Dead bởi Malcolm Brown
• Prospit Dreamers bởi Solatrus
• null bởi Toby Fox
• Noirscape bởi David Ellis
• Dogfight bởi Team Dogfight
• FantasyP bởi Erik Scheele
• Eternity Served Cold bởi Malcolm Brown
• Oppa Toby Style bởi Toby Fox
• Ascend bởi Tensei
• Renewed Return bởi Marcy Nabors

trong Fandom:

• Sburban Piano Doctor bởi Brad Griffin
• Satellite Physician bởi Joe Ouellet
• Prophecy bởi David Dycus
• The Demon and the Alien bởi Veritas Unae và David Ellis
• ♉ - Breathtak1ng bởi Rhyselinn
• Timeout bởi psithurist
• Homestuck Sonata (WIP) bởi David Ellis
• Penumbra Phat bởi Putnam
• turnways lurker bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• 25x SHOWDOWN COMBO bởi Cryptanark
• profesionalsism bởi Gordian
• Penumbra Phanteaseum bởi Interrobang
• sbruban trian bởi Gordian
• Mexican But Not Really bởi cookiefonster
• Doc Brown bởi Interrobang
• Postdoctoral Research Position bởi Interrobang
• Doctor of The Waking Phantasm (This Name Sucks) bởi Pipko Fanfare
• Moondoctor bởi Shwan
• Penumbra Phantasm By Toby Fox (Featuring "Radiation") bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• BeatVale bởi Cerulean
• Black Yard, Green Fun bởi Shwan
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi dbnet18
• The Connection bởi Kusoro
• cool and new community garden bởi cryptologicalMystic
• Garden of Cool and New bởi BitesizeBird
• Snow Phantasm bởi Difarem
• Penumbra Wubtasm (brief) bởi Makin
• Pebumbera bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• Approaching Foe bởi TirantBacon
• Showup bởi Viridian
• Masked Fox bởi BitesizeBird
• T3R3X1 STR1K3S B4CK bởi CreatorOfJanespeak
• FOCUS bởi Hadron
• you kiled swet bro prepair to di bởi TirantBacon
• stairdown (to be continue;}? bởi Cryptanark
• Revisit/Rewind bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• Dialup bởi Gordian
• Penumbran Phantasmia bởi luminantAegis
• The Ballad of Megan Pouring (instrumental) bởi Gordian
• Backtracking bởi Kusoro
• Hurt My Finger bởi Gordian
• Smooth Emergency bởi Viridian
• saoidfisd bởi Gordian
• －私はあなたを騙しました－( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) bởi Marcy Nabors và Jamie Paige
• sweet gains and hellish jhon bởi Cerulean
• swet bro rebibal bởi Wheals
• Intentional Unintentional Touhou bởi Viridian
• Moonwasher bởi Difarem
• Jaed Chaos bởi TirantBacon
• Of Bork and Yifs bởi Viridian
• Sunrise bởi Kusoro
• Medley bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• Battle Against A Baby President bởi Ray Mike
• Grimbark bởi Willow Ascenzo
• Dance of the Dead bởi Veritas Unae
• Shatter bởi Kanishka
• Homestuck Sonata bởi David Ellis
• Welcome to Quarantine City bởi Difarem và TirantBacon
• Vapor BLΛNKocity bởi WarxTron
• Year One bởi dbnet18
• Blastoff bởi dbnet18 với sự góp mặt của Husr
• Savoir Allegro (Bonus) bởi Husr
• Penumbra Phantasm (Frosty Style) bởi Frost Carter
• 8r8k the 8ottle bởi apatheticPianist và Pascal van den Bos
• Cue the Curtains bởi apatheticPianist và Pascal van den Bos
• Savior in a Blue Suit bởi dbnet18
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi dbnet18
• Infinity's Lament bởi Veritas Unae
• Part Ways Awayways bởi Mathias Ramalho
• Whispering Leviathan bởi Kanishka
• Congratulations on Updating the Comic! bởi Indubitably
• Calm Before the Storm bởi Cerulean
• Penumbra Hurbaderp bởi luminantAegis
• Prismatic Season bởi Beau Brian
• Gale Force Winds bởi Frost Carter
• Fireflies and Clockwork bởi apatheticPianist
• Troublemaker Tango bởi Pascal van den Bos
• Pascal "Don't call me Starkemeister" van den Bos and TimelessHeir's DX collab (gone wrong(gone sexual)) definitive edition bởi Rowyn Berlan và Pascal van den Bos
• Wind Awakening bởi Asian
• Ascend x10 Combo bởi Pascal van den Bos
• Awakened (Obobonus) bởi Ray Mike
• Indirectly, Hate You bởi Stacatto Force
• New and Improved bởi Cristata
• THE RAREST. AND MOST INTERPRETIVE. DANCE MEATCABRE. bởi keyboard cait
• Irrelevance Event Horizon bởi Kanishka
• Remember Me When I Am Gone Away bởi Kal-la-kal-la
• Ghost Hole bởi heir-of-puns
• A Handmaid's Last Stand bởi Rainy
• Spacetime Continuum bởi apatheticPianist và Pascal van den Bos
• Soft as the Clouds bởi WarxTron
• 🎼 Fraymotif ! bởi Tee-vee
• God Tier bởi Tee-vee
• Day One bởi Frost Carter
• 5 Years Older bởi Cerulean
• Final Phantasm bởi Pipko Fanfare
• Maritime Madness bởi Gryotharian
• 24/7 lo fi anime beats to achieve your destiny to bởi Frost Carter
• One Hour Later bởi Kusoro
• I Am Bigger Than This Story bởi Frost Carter
• i once swore to put penumbra phantasm into every homestuck project i work on until toby releases it but honestly this is getting ridiculous bởi Frost Carter
• RE:TCON bởi Tee-vee
• Prologue bởi Frost Carter
• Thief of Space bởi Cosmoptera
• Hivetown bởi Levc
• VS. Fiduspawner bởi Levc
• Seavilization bởi Levc
• Under A Starry Night Sky bởi monofe
• GALACTIC INCOHERENCE ~ Cosmic NaN Propagation bởi Cosmoptera
• Penumbral Awakening bởi ruby
• Stargazing with Gods bởi Rose Gray
• Homestuck 15th Anniversary Medley bởi tsundereCat [TC]
• The Twilight Reverie bởi Maukustus
• Strife! (Main Menu) bởi Pascal van den Bos
• A Gust of Dreams (John's Theme) bởi Pascal van den Bos và GITGOT
• Midnight Carnage (BOSS: Bec Noir) bởi Levc
• The Rainbow Maw (BOSS: Lord English) bởi Akisephila
• Cognitive Coalescence bởi Witch's Cadence
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM (Cover) bởi Ash Taylor
• If Then, Then Never bởi Spoofymaru
• Eight Ball of Destiny bởi ruby
• Collide2 bởi koba
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi Chipakeet
• Beneath the Shade bởi pomabug
• Blinking Clouds bởi pomabug
• Scratched bởi bould
• Senpai (Strider Mix) bởi bould
• Penumbra Phantasm (Ska) (Beta) bởi NeRd
• PENUMBRA // FANTHOLOGY bởi Interrobang
• Homeward Bound (CANMT Version) bởi WarxTron
• Penumbra Phantasm (Euro) (Beat) bởi NeRd
• Penumbra Phantasm (Jazz) (Bad) bởi NeRd

trong Beyond:

• Hopes and Dreams bởi Toby Fox
• SAVE the World bởi Toby Fox
• Last Goodbye bởi Toby Fox
• Toby Fox Has Written Hundreds of Unique Original Songs bởi jan Misali
• 𝐼𝒩𝒯𝐸𝑅𝐿𝒰𝒟𝐸- Elsewhere, in Another Time and Space, it Pours (ft Cozmia) bởi Cristata và hywell với sự góp mặt của Cozmia
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi kenji_shiro
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM (Dreemified) bởi Ash Dreemurr
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM bởi Checherex
• penumbra phantasm (cover) bởi Kot
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM bởi Ann
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM bởi Placek
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM bởi MG_Morgan
• Undying Energy bởi Gryotharian
• Darkest Place bởi bould
• Twilight Reverie ~ Penumbra Phantasm bởi Torrent 64 và Tee-vee
• Spectre of the Night bởi Witch's Cadence
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi Arkazitos

trong Additional Tracks:

• Chamber Complex bởi Tensei
• Ham And Steak bởi Malcolm Brown
• Penumbra Phantasm bởi ruby
• Ebgret bởi ostrichlittledungeon
• 半影の復帰 bởi Difarem
• PENUMBRA PHANTASM bởi surreal
• Savior of the Dreaming Dead (Cascade Cut) bởi Malcolm Brown
• normal song name bởi James Roach
• hell_tierwav bởi James Roach

Bài hát có đoạn trích từ Penumbra Phantasm:

trong Additional Tracks:

• this is like... what was it... > [S] MSPAR: Remember bởi James Roach

Các nguồn liên hệ: cho Penumbra Phantasm: Các nguồn liên hệ: cho Penumbra Phantasm…

24/2/2023 Makin và Niklink ✑ HSMusic Discord, excerpt

Makin:

ok question. does doctor reference penumbral phantasm, or is it the other way around?
the wiki doesnt say and i couldnt find the info anywhwere else online (albeit i only looked briefly). is that like. unknown? - Dyst

neither
the original pp was a melody that was quoted in savior of the waking world, which combines doctor and penumbra phantasm successfully and inspired a lot of pp remixes with doctor in them
and every version of PP that has leaked is post sotww I think
I guess you can make a case that all existing versions of PP reference doctor
definitely not the other way around

[...]

Niklink:
there's this one part of PP that sounds almost identical to the first few notes of doctor and they often get blurred together

4/10/2024 Jebb ✑ HSMusic Discord, excerpt

Jebb:
Well, very little is known about penumbra phantasm
It's referenced in like 1 toby track
Its melody is heavily based on Doctor's
There's a piano sketch and a tiny teaser i think
That's more or less it

20/5/2025 ruby ✑ HSMusic Discord, excerpt

ruby:
[...]
but the part of pp itself is undeniably based on doctor

22/11/2025 ruby, wertercatt, Rainy, Makin, Lilithtreasure, Jebb, and Lan ✑ HSMusic Discord, excerpt

ruby:
the riff in HaD is identical to pp, but it in pp is based on Doctor

[...]

wertercatt:
Should we stick a

                                Referenced Tracks:

                                - track:doctor
                                

onto Penumba by the way? Currently it's displayed as if it's a completely original track.

Rainy:
Yeah actually why wasn't that the case before

ruby:
[...]
because we established it's referencing penumbra
something from penumbra that is derived from doctor
[...]
onto penumbra? Yeah

wertercatt:
This track is presented as if it doesn't reference anything.

ruby:
surprising we don't
the main riff, while technically unique, is 100% based on doctor's

[...]

Makin:
I think it's just time to retire the "it's penumbra when doctor is one note off" and just admit it's a doctor variation that PP used

[...]

wertercatt:
Penumbra still needs Doctor added to its references tho.

[...]

Lilithtreasure:
it's surprising that penumbra isn't listed as referencing doctor, but patient is

Rainy:
yeah that's odd

Jebb:
Wait why does it not have doctor listed

Lan:
It's an oversight!!

[...]

Lan:
Guys, I swear, it's an oversight. This one - I do believe - is not intentional.