Skip to:

Penumbra Phantasm Penumbra Phantasm

Penumbra Phantasm Penumbra Phantasm

By Toby Fox tobyfox Bandcamp tobyfox Twitter toby.fangamer.com Other fwugradiation Tumblr Nautical Climb Previous track by this artist Plasmatic Blaquaciousness Next track by this artist.

Listen on YouTube or YouTube.

Read referencing sources.

Tracks that Penumbra Phantasm references:

Tracks that reference Penumbra Phantasm:

from Official Discography:
from Fandom:
from Beyond:
from Additional Tracks:

Tracks that sample Penumbra Phantasm:

from Additional Tracks:
Referencing sources for Penumbra Phantasm: Referencing sources for Penumbra Phantasm

Makin and NiklinkHSMusic Discord, excerpt

Makin:

ok question. does doctor reference penumbral phantasm, or is it the other way around?
the wiki doesnt say and i couldnt find the info anywhwere else online (albeit i only looked briefly). is that like. unknown? - Dyst

neither
the original pp was a melody that was quoted in savior of the waking world, which combines doctor and penumbra phantasm successfully and inspired a lot of pp remixes with doctor in them
and every version of PP that has leaked is post sotww I think
I guess you can make a case that all existing versions of PP reference doctor
definitely not the other way around

[...]

Niklink:
there's this one part of PP that sounds almost identical to the first few notes of doctor and they often get blurred together

JebbHSMusic Discord, excerpt

Jebb:
Well, very little is known about penumbra phantasm
It's referenced in like 1 toby track
Its melody is heavily based on Doctor's
There's a piano sketch and a tiny teaser i think
That's more or less it

rubyHSMusic Discord, excerpt

ruby:
[...]
but the part of pp itself is undeniably based on doctor

ruby, wertercatt, Rainy, Makin, Lilithtreasure, Jebb, and LanHSMusic Discord, excerpt

ruby:
the riff in HaD is identical to pp, but it in pp is based on Doctor

[...]

wertercatt:
Should we stick a


                                Referenced Tracks:
- track:doctor

onto Penumba by the way? Currently it's displayed as if it's a completely original track.

Rainy:
Yeah actually why wasn't that the case before

ruby:
[...]
because we established it's referencing penumbra
something from penumbra that is derived from doctor
[...]
onto penumbra? Yeah

wertercatt:
This track is presented as if it doesn't reference anything.

ruby:
surprising we don't
the main riff, while technically unique, is 100% based on doctor's

[...]

Makin:
I think it's just time to retire the "it's penumbra when doctor is one note off" and just admit it's a doctor variation that PP used

[...]

wertercatt:
Penumbra still needs Doctor added to its references tho.

[...]

Lilithtreasure:
it's surprising that penumbra isn't listed as referencing doctor, but patient is

Rainy:
yeah that's odd

Jebb:
Wait why does it not have doctor listed

Lan:
It's an oversight!!

[...]

Lan:
Guys, I swear, it's an oversight. This one - I do believe - is not intentional.

View original file ( kB MB). (Heads up! If you're on a mobile plan, this is a large download.)